This publication has been produced with the assistance of the European Union. The contents of the publication is the sole responsibility of City of Lieksa and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the European Union.
Background. Muezersky District and the City of Lieksa are
interested in developing cross-border links, strengthening socio-cultural
contacts. Construction of the "Inari" cross-border motor vehicle checkpoint is
their common task, on which solution future development of the two territories
depends. Feasibility study for the development of the Inari cross-border
checkpoint is a first step in the collaborative work.
In full, the feasibility study occupies 94 pages of the A4 format and comprises
the assessment of the current state of the checkpoint, calculations of the load
on the planned Inari cross-border checkpoint, forecast of the dynamics of the
cargo and tourist traffic across the checkpoint, general technical
characteristics and estimate of the cost-efficiency and return rate for the
investments in developing the Inari checkpoint.
Current state of the Inari checkpoint. The Inari checkpoint
is situated in the north of the Russian-Finnish border, at the same latitude as
the City of Lieksa, c. 70 km east of it. Roads leading to the checkpoint on the
Finnish side are in good condition. The following parameters characterise the
activities of the Inari simple-procedure checkpoint:
Border crossing indices
2001
in 10 months of 2002
No of customs declarations
342
570
Cargo volumes (1000 ton)
155,05
220,89
Customs duties levied (million roubles)
18,02
12,04
No of motor vehicles (units)
10928
10419
Individuals (alien), no of persons
11349
10796
Customs inspection statements (units)
64
48
Today, the Inari checkpoint serves 5.4% of all cargo transport
border crossings through all five simple-procedure checkpoints.
Forecast of cargo traffic across the Inari cross-border
checkpoint. Muezersky District contains 7.8% of the total length of motor
roads in Karelia. The density of motor roads in the district is c. 30km/1000 sq.
km (the average for Karelia is 37 km/1000 sq. km). The motor cargo traffic in
the district is 37.8 million ton-km (total for Karelia is 1267 million ton-km).
The passenger traffic in the district is 1.1 million passenger-km.
Three potential scenarios of the cargo traffic dynamics across Muezersky
District were developed within the project: pessimistic, moderate and
optimistic. The forecasts were based on data on the scope and intensity of
natural resource utilisation, number of enterprises and production volumes,
quality of the transport infrastructure, foundation of new manufacturing
businesses in the district.
The results for the three forecasted scenarios are shown in the table:
Border crossing indices
2007
2008
2009
2010
Pessimistic forecast
Total cargo volumes, ton/year
132000
151800
166980
175329
No of motor vehicles, vehicle/year
18149
20872
22959
24107
Optimistic forecast
Total cargo volumes, ton/year
352117,5
404935,1
445428,6
467700,0
No of motor vehicles, vehicle/year
41984
48282
53110
55765
Moderate forecast
Total cargo volumes, ton/year
246482,3
283454,6
311800,1
327390,1
No of motor vehicles, vehicle/year
30352
34905
38396
40316
Forecast of tourist traffic across the Inari cross-border
checkpoint. Three potential scenarios are suggested also for the dynamics of
tourist traffic across the Inari cross-border checkpoint: optimistic,
pessimistic and moderate. It is expected that about 60% of all tourists
would be foreign citizens coming to the Muezersky District to practice nature
and water-sport tourism. Keeping this in mind, the following differentiation is
assumed for the tourist traffic across the Inari cross-border checkpoint:
there will be few large groups of tourists coming by bus (30% of the total
tourist traffic at maximum);
the bulk of tourists will be small groups and singular tourists arriving
by private cars (60% or more).
The results for the three forecasted scenarios are shown in the table:
Border crossing indices
2007 (estimate)
2008 (estimate)
2009 (estimate)
2010 (estimate)
Pessimistic scenario
Total tourist traffic, man/year
20000
23000
25300
26565
Passenger vehicles, vehicle/year
11033
12688
13957
14654
Optimistic scenario
Total tourist traffic, man/year
40000
46000
50600
53130
Passenger vehicles, vehicle/year
19267
22157
24373
25591
Moderate scenario
Total tourist traffic, man/year
30000
34500
37950
39848
Passenger vehicles, vehicle/year
14450
16618
18279
19194
Planned handling capacity of the Inari cross-border checkpoint.
According to predictive calculations, the checkpoint handling
capacity will be 40,000 vehicles/year and 90,000 ind./year (i.e. 110
vehicles/day and 250 ind./day), the average traffic being 20,000 vehicles/year
and 60,000 ind./year (i.e. 55 vehicles/day and 170 ind./day).
Most of the time, the Inari cross-border checkpoint will operate at 60-70% of
the potential capacity. With a checkpoint with such handling capacity
established, one can expert the demand for border crossing services in the
Muezersky District to be fully satisfied.
The Inari cross-border checkpoint will specialise in three activities:
services to logging enterprises of the Muezersky District and their Finnish
partners (roundwood export from Russia);
services to cross-border activities;
services to European and Russian tourists.
Requirements to the organisation of the Inari cross-border
checkpoint comply with international requirements to the operation of
cross-border checkpoints. The following has to be accomplished for the Inari
cross-border checkpoint to be put into operation:
construction of new operational facilities;
acquisition of special equipment for frontier control;
staff training in compliance with new operational methods and modes;
repair of the main road to the village of Lendery, other roads and bridges
in the stretch from the border to the village of Lendery.
Planning documents on the Inari cross-border checkpoint are prepared taking
into account the need to accommodate the following service units: customs,
frontier and migration services, motor licensing and inspection department,
Russian Federation Ministry of Foreign Affairs office, veterinary, phytosanitary
and sanitary-epidemiological inspectorates.
Estimate of the project costs, cost-efficiency and investment
return time for the Inari cross-border checkpoint. The time by which the
Inari cross-border checkpoint achieves the planned capacity stipulated in
predictive calculations is 2007. The duration of the investment phase of the
project is 3 years. Investments into the Inari cross-border checkpoint
development amount to EUR 3,920,000:
Costs
RUR 1000
EUR 1000
Construction of cross-border infrastructure
24480,0
720,0
Including:
construction of utility facilities
8840,0
260,0
equipment for frontier control
15640,0
460,0
training in new working methods
4420,0
130,0
Repair of roads, bridges, water conduits
79900,0
2350,0
TOTAL PROJECT COST
133280,0
3920,0
Estimates of the cost-efficiency and investment return rate for the Inari
cross-border checkpoint were based on the aggregate effect from the activities
of the checkpoint:
Kinds of economic effect
2007 (estimate)
2008 (estimate)
2009 (estimate)
2010
(estimate)
Total income from tourism
24954,9
29845,1
34118,7
37208,1
Tax proceeds in budgets of all levels
64878,4
71166,4
80158,1
93444,4
Effect from reduced transport costs
13905,8
15991,1
17590,2
18470,3
Aggregate economic effect
105746,1
119010,6
133876
151132,8
Progressive total aggregate effect
105746,1
224756,7
358632,7
509765,5
Three options were considered when estimating the economic efficiency of
investing into the construction of the Inari cross-border checkpoint:
Option "A" - only the increase in tax proceeds in the budgets
of all levels from the opening of the Inari cross-border checkpoint are taken
into account.
Option "B" - income from tourism development and reduction of
transport costs owing to the opening of the Inari cross-border checkpoint are
taken into account.
Option "C" - all the three kinds of income are taken into account.
The results of estimating the economic efficiency for the three options are
as follows:
Option
NPV, EUR 1000
IRR, %
PI
PB, months
Option "A"
9135,67
64,02
3,51
41
Option "B"
4058,72
36,35
2,11
50
Option "C"
17384,58
99,59
5,78
36
Calculations indicate that implementation of the project
for the development of the Inari cross-border checkpoint would be efficient.
Results of the sensitivity and resistance analysis show that the project is
highly resistant to most external economic risks.